For hindus, cows are sacred and cannot be slaughtered they wander freely, defecating wherever marvin harris has an etic explanation for this set of beliefs. They claim that analysis from this point of view shows that the number of cattle is not excessive, that the so-called and marvin harris, who graciously provided us with a copy of his recent paper (harris difficulty in the sacred-cow controversy india is so vast and. The sacred cow controversy essay sample a lot of debate has been carried about the indian sacred cow the term sacred cow originates for india meaning that the cow is worshiped, and has always been sacrosanct and inviolable. Cows are considered sacred by hindus in india they were the favorite animal of lord krishna, and they serve as a symbol of wealth, strength, and abundance.
Harris (1966) argued that the sacred cow could be traced to a combination of factors, including a reliance on cattle for plowing and demographic and environmental constraints. His work with india’s sacred cow myth (1966) is seen by many as his most successful cm analysis (ross 1980) in this work, harris considers the taboo against cow consumption in india, demonstrating how economic and technological factors within the infrastructure affect the other two sectors of culture, resulting in superstructural ideology. Marvin harris, india's sacred cow: an article from the cultural anthropologist holy cow: hinduism's sacred animal , nature, pbs: background materials for a 2004 american public television documentary.
Suggests that india's sacred cow is in fact quite a rational cultural adaptation -- because the cow is so extraordinarily useful news photographs that came out of india during the famine of the late 1960s showed. India's sacred cow in this article, marvin harris challenges the view that religious value is ecologically irrational dealing with the indian case, he argues that indian cattle, far from. But what actually may be most charac- teristic of the size of india's herd is the low ratio harris : india's sacred cattle of cattle to people thus, india has 44 cattle per 100 persons, while in the us the ratio is 58 per 100 and in canada, 90 (mamoria 1953:256. Even if foreign loans were to provide the money, the capital outlay necessary to replace the indian cow with tractors and fertilizers for the fields, coal for the fires, and transportation for the family would probably warp international financial institutions for years” (harris, “sacred cows”, p 205.
The cultural ecology of india's sacred cattle : marvin harris milk production despite the huge number of cattle, the milk production is less than 3/4th as compared to any other part of the world. Read the following article and answer the questions at the end india’s sacred cow by marvin harris (paraphrased) news photographs that came out of india during the famine of the late 1960s showed starving people stretching out bony hands to beg for food while cattle strolled behind them undisturbed. 18 india's sacred cow marvin harris other people's religious practices and beliefs may often appear to be wasteful they seem to involve a large expenditure of scarce resources on ritual they contain taboos that restrict the use of apparently useful materials. Marvin harris shows that cows, wandering everywhere in india, eat waste like rice straw and husks they provide bull calves that grow up and plow the soil their dung, in a land stripped of trees, is a hot. Marvin harris marvin harris india’s sacred cow 1 marvin harris 3 the practical role of the cow, cow provide less than half the milk produced in india most cows in india are not dairy breeds the cow is the most sacred because it can produce ox and calves.
While reading the article india’s sacred cow by marvin harris (1978) i was able to gain insight about the hindu people and their reasons for “worshipping” the “sacred cows” (harris, 1978. Start studying india's sacred cow - marvin harris learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Harris argues that there was a spiritual explanation behind why the cow had become deemed a sacred animal as far back as 200 ad, brahmin priests had began stressing the divine nature of the cow.
Although i know too little of the other approaches considered to be able to evaluate harris' criticisms, he appears to have done a very effective hatchet job on many of the sacred cows of anthropology (and the indian sacred cow complex is one of his major examples. Marvin harris (august 18, 1927 – october 25, 2001) was an american anthropologist he was born in brooklyn , new york city a prolific writer, he was highly influential in the development of cultural materialism. Although ethnography was the signature of american anthropology at the time that marvin harris wrote “the cultural ecology of india’s sacred cattle,” he felt as though etic studies with information derived from empirical studies were more scientific and, therefore, more valid than emic approaches.